| All-Time All-Scandal Team |
| Position |
Name |
| C |
Paul Lo Duca |
| 1B |
Mark McGwire |
| 2B |
Billy Martin |
| SS | Miguel Tejada |
| 3B |
Wade Boggs |
| LF |
Barry Bonds |
| CF |
Ty Cobb |
| RF |
Darryl Strawberry |
| DH |
Jose Canseco |
| P |
Eddie Cicotte |
| P |
Claude "Lefty" Williams |
| P |
Roger Clemens |
| P |
Dwight Gooden |
| P |
Denny McLain |
| P |
La Marr Hoyt |
| P |
Fritz Peterson |
| P |
Mike Kekich |
| P |
Steve Howe |
| P |
John Rocker |
| Bench |
Albert Belle |
| Bench |
Mickey Mantle |
| Bench |
Rafael Palmeiro |
| Bench |
Lenny Dykstra |
| Bench |
Dave Parker |
Bench |
Sammy Sosa |
| Manager |
Pete Rose |
General Manager |
Steve Phillips |
| Owner |
George Steinbrenner |
| Trainer |
Brian McNamee |
| Mascot |
Pirate Parrot |