| Detroit Tigers All-Stars |
| Year |
Player(s) |
| 2008 |
Carlos Guillen, 3B |
| 2007 |
Ivan Rodriguez*, Magglio Ordonez*, Placido Polanco, Carlos Guillen, Justin Verlander |
| 2006 |
Ivan Rodriguez, Magglio Ordonez, Kenny Rogers |
| 2005 |
Ivan Rodriguez |
| 2004 |
Carlos Guillen‡, Ivan Rodriguez* |
| 2003 |
Dmitri Young |
| 2002 |
Robert Fick |
| 2001 |
Tony Clark |
| 2000 |
Todd Jones |
| 1999 |
Brad Ausmus |
| 1998 |
Damion Easley |
| 1997 |
Justin Thompson |
| 1996 |
Travis Fryman |
| 1995 |
David Wells |
| 1994 |
Travis Fryman, Mickey Tettleton |
| 1993 |
Cecil Fielder, Travis Fryman |
| 1992 |
Travis Fryman |
| 1991 |
Cecil Fielder* |
| 1990 |
Cecil Fielder, Alan Trammell |
| 1989 |
Mike Henneman‡ |
| 1988 |
Doyle Alexander‡, Alan Trammell*† |
| 1987 |
Jack Morris, Matt Nokes, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker† |
| 1986 |
Willie Hernandez, Lance Parrish*, Lou Whitaker* |
| 1985 |
Willie Hernandez‡, Jack Morris*, Lance Parrish*†, Dan Petry, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker* |
| 1984 |
Willie Hernandez, Chet Lemon*, Jack Morris, Lance Parrish*, Alan Trammell†, Lou Whitaker* |
| 1983 |
Aurelio Lopez‡, Lance Parrish, Lou Whitaker |
| 1982 |
Lance Parrish |
| 1981 |
Jack Morris* |
| 1980 |
Lance Parrish, Alan Trammell |
| 1979 |
Steve Kemp |
| 1978 |
Jason Thompson |
| 1977 |
Mark Fidrych†, Jason Thompson‡ |
| 1976 |
Mark Fidrych*, Ron LeFlore*, Rusty Staub* |
| 1975 |
Bill Freehan‡ |
| 1974 |
John Hiller‡, Al Kaline |
| 1973 |
Ed Brinkman, Bill Freehan‡, Willie Horton |
| 1972 |
Norm Cash, Bill Freehan*, Mickey Lolich |
| 1971 |
Norm Cash*, Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline, Mickey Lolich |
| 1970 |
Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton |
| 1969 |
Bill Freehan*, Mickey Lolich‡, Denny McLain |
| 1968 |
Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton*, Denny McLain, Don Wert |
| 1967 |
Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline*†, Dick McAuliffe |
| 1966 |
Norm Cash, Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline, Dick McAuliffe*, Denny McLain* |
| 1965 |
Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton*, Al Kaline, Dick McAuliffe* |
| 1964 |
Bill Freehan‡, Al Kaline†, Jerry Lumpe‡ |
| 1963 |
Jim Bunning, Al Kaline* |
| 1962 (Game 2) |
Hank Aguirre, Jim Bunning‡, Rocky Colavito, Al Kaline |
| 1962 (Game 1) |
Hank Aguirre‡, Jim Bunning, Rocky Colavito |
| 1961 (Game 2) |
Jim Bunning, Norm Cash*, Al Kaline |
| 1961 (Game 1) |
Jim Bunning, Norm Cash*, Al Kaline, Frank Lary |
| 1960 (Game 2) |
Al Kaline, Frank Lary |
| 1960 (Game 1) |
Al Kaline, Frank Lary |
| 1959 (Game 2) |
Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn† |
| 1959 (Game 1) |
Jim Bunning, Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn |
| 1958 |
Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn |
| 1957 |
Jim Bunning*, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn*, Charlie Maxwell |
| 1956 |
Ray Boone, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn*, Charlie Maxwell‡ |
| 1955 |
Billy Hoeft‡, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn* |
| 1954 |
Ray Boone*, Harvey Kuenn‡ |
| 1953 |
Harvey Kuenn |
| 1952 |
Vic Wertz‡ |
| 1951 |
Fred Hutchinson, George Kell*, Vic Wertz |
| 1950 |
Hoot Evers*, Ted Gray, Art Houtteman, George Kell* |
| 1949 |
George Kell*, Virgil Trucks, Vic Wertz |
| 1948 |
Hoot Evers*, George Kell‡, Pat Mullin*, Hal Newhouser |
| 1947 |
George Kell*, Pat Mullin‡, Hal Newhouser*, Dizzy Trout‡ |
| 1946 |
Hal Newhouser |
| 1945 |
Hank Greenberg‡ (See note at bottom) |
| 1944 |
Pinky Higgins, Hal Newhouser, Dizzy Trout‡, Rudy York‡ |
| 1943 |
Hal Newhouser, Dick Wakefield*, Rudy York |
| 1942 |
Al Benton, Hal Newhouser‡, Birdie Tebbetts*, Rudy York* |
| 1941 |
Al Benton‡, Birdie Tebbetts‡, Rudy York* |
| 1940 |
Tommy Bridges‡, Hank Greenberg*, Bobo Newsom |
| 1939 |
Tommy Bridges, Hank Greenberg*, Bobo Newsom‡ |
| 1938 |
Charlie Gehringer*, Hank Greenberg†, Vern Kennedy‡, Rudy York |
| 1937 |
Tommy Bridges, Charlie Gehringer*, Hank Greenberg‡, Gee Walker† |
| 1936 |
Tommy Bridges†, Charlie Gehringer*, Goose Goslin, Schoolboy Rowe |
| 1935 |
Tommy Bridges‡, Mickey Cochrane‡, Charlie Gehringer*, Schoolboy Rowe‡ |
| 1934 |
Tommy Bridges‡, Mickey Cochrane, Charlie Gehringer* |
| 1933 |
Charlie Gehringer* |
